Search

Most Australians now believe ‘tainted’ Pat Cummins is a liar. That could force stalling bosses to sack him - if captain doesn’t quit first, writes LAWRENCE BOOTH

As Pat Cummins was doorstepped at his Sydney home by reporters clamouring for reaction to Cameron Bancroft’s accusations the night before, it was clear Australia’s public mood had taken a turn for the febrile.

Six days earlier, Cummins appeared to have grabbed the momentum during a marathon press conference in which he called Usman Khawaja’s claim that the whole team knew about the 2018 sandpaper plot in South Africa ‘complete and utter nonsense’.

But his credibility took a hit, first when Chadd Sayers – 12th man in South Africa – backed Khawaja’s version of events on Sunday. Then, even more devastatingly, on Wednesday evening, when Bancroft planted his 4,497-word detonation in the West Australian, effectively branding Cummins a liar.

Code Sports, the Australian sports news website, has been running polls all week to determine whether the public are with Team Khawaja or Team Cummins. And until Bancroft’s revelations, the result was too close to call.

Now, though, the split has lurched to 80-20 in Khawaja’s favour. Four out of five Aussies, in other words, no longer believe Cummins has been truthful. It is an approval rating which might make even Donald Trump think twice.

One of the reporters pursuing Cummins to his car as he headed for training suggested the ‘English media’ thought he should be sacked, as if it were all a Pommie plot. But that downplays the extent to which the Australian press also believe his position is increasingly untenable.

Aussie skipper Pat Cummins appeared to have grabbed the momentum during a marathon press conference in which he denied Usman Khawaja’s Sandpapergate claims – but the mood has now changed

Cameron Bancroft’s revelations in the Australian media effectively branded Cummins a liar

The golden boy who has captained his country to World Cup and World Test Championship success in 2023, and possesses a Test record – 328 wickets at 22 – to compare with anyone, is close to being hung, drawn and quartered in the court of public opinion.

And it is that court whose approval Cricket Australia have always craved. It was the Test team’s reputation-damaging five defeats in a row in 2016 that led to board officials laying down the law to the players, which in turn created the win-at-all-costs toxicity that spawned the use of sandpaper.

If CA now conclude that Cummins is damaged goods, that the job often described as the second-most important in Australia behind the prime minister has been sullied by association, they will have no choice but to sack him.

That assumes Cummins won’t jump before he is pushed, possibly on the pretext that he has become a ‘distraction’, since it is inconceivable that he will backtrack on the clear-eyed certainty of last week’s denial.

It emerged on Wednesday that Australia’s selectors had delayed naming their Test squad for December’s four-match series at home to New Zealand, ostensibly because they wanted to use the next round of first-class Sheffield Shield matches, starting on Sunday, to finalise their options.

But since none of Cummins, Josh Hazlewood or Mitchell Starc – the three frontline fast bowlers in South Africa eight years ago – is expected to turn out for New South Wales against Queensland at Sydney, it is hard to avoid the suspicion that CA are stalling, while they wait to see what other revelations crop up in the meantime.

CA chief executive, Todd Greenberg, looked impressively calm as he passed through Hobart Airport on Thursday morning, having announced during a bizarre press conference by a children’s playground that an ‘independent forum’ would be established to create a ‘safe space’ for the Class of 2018 to talk about Sandpapergate.

And while Greenberg is understood not to favour any action either immediate or drastic, neither can he afford to ignore the outside noise.

Cricket Australia chief executive, Todd Greenberg, is understood not to favour any action either immediate or drastic but he knows he cannot afford to ignore the outside noise

Australia have delayed naming their squad for December’s Test series with New Zealand so it remains to be seen if the famous bowling quartet of (from left) Josh Hazlewood, Nathan Lyon, Mitchell Starc and Cummins will be selected

It was instructive, for instance, that former Test wicketkeeper Ian Healy, whose niece Alyssa – herself an ex-international keeper – is married to Starc, said Bancroft’s testimony ‘taints the personal legacies’ of the bowlers.

Veteran journalist and broadcaster Robert Craddock was unequivocal, insisting: ‘It’s legacy-damaging. There’s no question about it.’

Part of CA’s problem is that they have invested heavily in the idea of Cummins as the figurehead of the Good Ship Australia, steering the boat away from the choppy waters created by the team coached by Darren Lehmann. Even Cummins himself called the atmosphere under Lehmann ‘ugly’.

Not only that, but he inherited the captaincy shortly before the 2021-22 Ashes, when Tim Paine was forced to step down because it turned out he had sent explicit messages to a Cricket Tasmania employee four years earlier.

Quite simply, Australian cricket needed Cummins – tall, handsome and articulate, a clean slate for a new era – to help win back the fans’ affection. When Greenberg argued on Wednesday that ‘the captain doesn’t need to be cleared’, it sounded like wishful thinking as much as anything, a plea for the sanity of the Australian game.

And yet the prevailing mood out here these past few days has been one of catharsis, with first Khawaja’s, then Bancroft’s claims, bringing to the surface all manner of emotions.

Bancroft himself, answering questions through his car window the morning after he burned the house down, said: ‘I didn’t want to point fingers or implicate the others. I just wanted for my own peace to tell the truth. I feel freed and happy.’

Bancroft tucks the sandpaper into his pocket during that infamous Cape Town Test in 2018. Having told his story he says he now feels ‘freed and happy’

The Aussie coach during Sandpapergate, Darren Lehmann, cut a distressed figure in the Hobart press box when the Bancroft news broke

But Lehmann, who had been in Hobart to commentate on the barely noticed third ODI between Australia and England, cut a distressed figure in the press box when the Bancroft news broke.

And Peter Handscomb, the substitute who Bancroft claimed had been told by Lehmann at Cape Town to ‘get the f*****g sandpaper off Bangers now’ when the cameras exposed the skulduggery, was also on commentary duty – as if to emphasise the story’s continued resonance in every nook and cranny of the Australian game.

Very few figures have emerged from this episode with credit. In Bancroft’s telling, only CA’s media manager on the South Africa tour, Kate Hutchison, spoke out against the stupidity.

There are almost no heroes here, only cricketers and former coaches fighting for reputations, and reporters roaming the streets conducting vox pops. Everyone has an opinion. And it is turning against Australia’s Test captain.

More stories