Former Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) player Dinesh Karthik expressed his surprise at India opting not to include Mohammed Siraj in the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand at the Basin Reserve in Wellington. The senior player did not find a place in the side despite the visitors going all out with four frontline pacers, including Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep.
Mohammed Siraj, who featured in only one ODI in the recently concluded five-match series, was expected to play a massive role in the Test matches alongside the returning Jasprit Bumrah.
However, the team management went in a different direction, with skipper Shubman Gill admitting at the toss that it was a tough decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out.
Dinesh Karthik failed to understand the team’s logic behind the decision and believes Mohammed Siraj could have been the answer to New Zealand’s recovery on Day 1.
“What shocked me was Siraj not being there, why? I did not see that coming, I have to be honest. I genuinely thought it was going to be Bumrah and Siraj, and the other two pacers between the other options. We have to understand that when Bumrah was not there in England, Siraj took over as the lead bowler, and you felt that he was a sure-shot lock-in,” Dinesh Karthik said on Cricbuzz.
“In these types of conditions, I saw him play; unless he is given enough evidence by the support staff that they have not been happy with what he has done in India ‘A’ game, or the ODI, and the net sessions, I find it hard to fathom, and to an extent, accept, because I really thought it would be Bumrah and Siraj leading the attack. I don’t think it is to have batting depth, because they have played four seamers, and none of them can give you much with the bat,” he added.
The Indian seamers dominated the opening session on Day 1, leaving New Zealand reeling at 70-5 at one stage. However, the pair of Glenn Phillips and Henry Nicholls staged a massive recovery through an unbeaten 173-run partnership to end the day at 243-5.
“Once the Nicholls-Phillips partnership started, they almost found it hard to pick up wickets. They did not create too many opportunities. That is where the inexperience came in a little bit, and that is where you think would Siraj have been able to do something in that middle phase?” Dinesh Karthik added.
Jasprit Bumrah was the pick of the bowlers with figures of 3-52 in 17 overs, while Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep chipped in with a wicket apiece.
“I do feel that is justified” - Dinesh Karthik’s huge take on India’s decision to bench Ravindra Jadeja in NZ vs IND 2026 1st Test
Another senior figure who failed to make it to the playing XI alongside Mohammed Siraj was all-rounder Ravindra Jadeja. After confirming before the match that India would only field one spinner in the combination, Shubman Gill named off-spinner Washington Sundar over the veteran.
Dinesh Karthik opined that the call makes sense to an extent because of the match-up Washington Sundar offers against New Zealand’s heavy left-handed batting unit.
“What we didn’t see coming was, Washington Sundar ahead of Ravindra Jadeja and I do feel that is justified because of the number of left-handers being there and the confidence with which Gautam Gambhir believes in Washington Sundar - the batter, so that is justified to a large extent, even though Ravindra Jadeja is experienced, I feel that Sundar’s off-spin could come into play later on in the Test match. I can almost breathe easy and sleep easy on that,” Dinesh Karthik said.
The spin all-rounder bowled 16 overs on Day 1, conceding only 38 runs at an economy of 2.40. He was the second-most economical bowler for India, placed narrowly behind Akash Deep.
Looking for fast live cricket scores? Download CricRocket and get fast score updates, top-notch commentary in-depth match stats & much more! 🚀☄️

