Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has expressed surprise at the manner in which Pat Cummins responded to Usman Khawaja’s claims regarding the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, saying the controversy appears to have exposed lingering divisions within the Australian dressing room. In his autobiography Sabr: Finding My Way in Cricket and Life, Khawaja claimed that the entire Australian team was aware of the ball-tampering plot, despite Cricket Australia’s investigation finding only Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft guilty of involvement. Australia Test captain Cummins dismissed the allegations as “100 per cent wrong” and “complete and utter nonsense”, insisting neither he nor the bowlers were aware that sandpaper had been taken onto the field.
“Firstly, when Usman Khawaja has mentioned certain things in his book, those are his accounts of the story and we need to respect that. But what happened at Pat Cummins’ press conference is that he didn’t discredit Usman Khawaja’s account of the story; he discredited the man himself. And that is the problem for me,” Ashwin said on JioStar.
“When you can’t discredit someone’s information, you discredit the person. I know Usman Khawaja. I’ve played a lot of cricket with him. He is a man of high integrity and a very honest and straightforward person.”
Ashwin pointed out that Cummins, who was still relatively early in his international career at the time, was unlikely to have been part of the leadership group, which he believes included Smith, Warner and possibly Tim Paine.
“I genuinely thought that this conversation would have centred around saying, ‘I wasn’t aware of what exactly was happening. I wasn’t a part of the leadership group.’”
“It was very surprising for me that Pat Cummins had to come to the press conference and discredit the person himself. That was a little bit of a shock to me, watching from afar,” Ashwin said.
During the third Test against South Africa in Cape Town in March 2018, Bancroft was caught on camera using sandpaper on the ball, leading to lengthy bans for Smith, Warner and Bancroft.
“Pat Cummins, who I really admire as a cricketer, is the captain of Australia and, alongside Tim Paine, took on the responsibility of rebuilding Australian cricket after that incident.”
“He has come out and called what Khawaja has said baseless, nonsense and something that does not have proof.”
“David Warner has continued to maintain his own version of events. So one thing is crystal clear: there were cracks in that Australian dressing room in terms of views and opinions on this issue, and I don’t think those cracks have completely disappeared even now,” Ashwin added.
Former Australia pacer Chadd Sayers has also backed Khawaja’s version of events, claiming everyone in the squad knew about the plan and revealing that, as 12th man, he had removed sandpaper from the field during the Port Elizabeth Test, the match before Cape Town.
“At the end of this, Usman Khawaja has made one thing very clear: he is asking for collective accountability.”
“He is saying, quite accurately in this case, that it was not only three people who knew about it; there were more.”
“With what we have heard from Chadd Sayers and what Usman Khawaja is saying, that already makes it five people. So he is right,” Ashwin said.
‘Supporters Deserve Clear Answers’: Hayden
Former Australia opener Matthew Hayden said supporters of the game deserve greater clarity regarding the controversy.
“The fundamental question here is: what was damaged, and why is it relevant?” Hayden said.
“It’s simple. When integrity is broken, trust is damaged. These new accounts have reopened questions about accountability. In my opinion, supporters deserve clear answers.”
“Eight years passing doesn’t automatically resolve the hurt or the disagreement,” he added.
Former India pacer Irfan Pathan also questioned whether the original investigation had gone far enough.
“It’s not possible that, if the ball is reverse swinging, I as a bowler wouldn’t know if something had been done to it. I would know straight away.”
“If Australian cricket and its supporters want answers, then the investigation should start again,” Pathan said.
CWG 2026 Weightlifting Gold Medallist, Mirabai Chanu Get Hero’s Welcome in Delhi
