Former Indian cricketer Dinesh Karthik feels that Mohammed Siraj has been left out of the playing XI for the fourth ODI against New Zealand for multiple reasons, while adding that he is slipping in the pecking order for the 2027 World Cup. The right-arm pacer is yet to make an appearance in the ongoing series, with Arshdeep Singh spearheading the attack.
Mohammed Siraj’s wait extended again at Bay Oval in Mount Maunganui as he was not considered despite Anshul Kamboj’s absence. He was unavailable for the opener in Auckland because he was finishing an unofficial Test for India A against New Zealand A, a match that ended on November 3.
He joined the squad in Wellington before the second ODI and did not play. The third ODI in Hamilton was washed out without a ball bowled, though the toss took place with India naming an XI without him. India fielded four specialist seamers across those games, with Arshdeep, Aaqib Nabi, Anshul Kamboj and Gurnoor Brar sharing the work while the visitors took a 2-0 lead.
Anshul Kamboj left the squad along with Shubman Gill and KL Rahul to begin preparations for the two-Test series starting in Wellington on November 19. However, instead of a straight swap in the bowling unit, India picked Kuldeep Yadav, with Shreyas Iyer leading in Gill’s absence and Ishan Kishan and Ruturaj Gaikwad also returning.
Dinesh Karthik believes that the success of the current bowling unit in New Zealand and the team management’s desire for batting depth leaves no place for Siraj in the side.
“The sad part of that XI is Mohammed Siraj. I think he has not made the cut purely because of two things: How well Arshdeep and Gurnoor have bowled, and India do want to bat till No.8. I think they feel Aaqib Nabi is someone who can give them something with the bat at No.8 and hence he makes the cut. At this point of time, he is not on the top of the pile for the 2027 World Cup. I think there are a couple of bowlers who are ahead of him. This is from the Indian team’s perspective, personally it’s different,” Karthik said on Cricbuzz.
Mohammed Siraj is among the most experienced seamers in the current bowling unit, with 77 wickets in 51 ODIs, but only 10 ODIs and nine wickets since the 2023 World Cup final, at an average of 47.44. He was not called up as Jasprit Bumrah’s replacement for the 2025 Champions Trophy either.
Former India spinner Murali Kartik also expressed his disappointment at the team management’s call.
“I don’t understand it, but it is how the team sees him. We can sit here and feel for him. I don’t know whether he was at his best in the hot and humid conditions in Sri Lanka, but post that, he has not been needed in the playing XI. I hope Siraj gets a gig because he is a whole-hearted cricketer,” Murali Kartik said.
The senior pacer is a part of the squad for the upcoming two-match Test series and is expected to play a key role with the red-ball.
“It is a very interesting move to bring Kuldeep” - Dinesh Karthik on India’s decision to include a frontline spinner for NZ vs IND 2026 4th ODI
Kuldeep Yadav had been with the squad throughout the ODI and T20I series without a game, with Axar and Dhir handling the spin duties for the majority of the time. India have only included a frontline spinner once on the entire tour, when Varun Chakravarthy featured in the dead-rubber T20I series finale.
“It is a very interesting move to bring Kuldeep, which tells you that the pitch is definitely a lot flatter than what we have seen in the last two games. Kuldeep has been part of the side, but just has not been able to make it to the XI. The fact that he has made the playing XI for this game means that they are expecting this pitch to turn a little bit,” Dinesh Karthik said.
The Indian bowling unit has struggled a bit on a batting-friendly track after the contrasting conditions in Auckland and Wellington. At the time of writing, New Zealand are placed at 102-2 after 16 overs.
Looking for fast live cricket scores? Download CricRocket and get fast score updates, top-notch commentary in-depth match stats & much more! 🚀☄️
